It’s Not About George Floyd



It’s Not About George Floyd


“The veneer of civilization is very thin”

 – David Pettys,

                                                                         Marine Helicopter Pilot on returning from Vietnam


Officer Derek Chauvin’s knee on George Floyd’s neck is a metaphor for how the elites are cutting off air of the bottom 50% or 60% of this country. Healthcare. Housing. Education. Jobs. It cannot continue indefinitely without an explosion.

My home town of Redwood City is bracing for chaos, looting, street fighting tomorrow night.




My beloved Talk of Broadway restaurant is all boarded up, as are many other businesses. I talked to the owner today, John Lee: “I have to protect my restaurant. If I don’t, they will break in and set it on fire. It is the livelihood for me and my family.”


Throughout human history, when the ruling elites get too greedy, after generations of abuse, the little people rise up and tear it all down, i.e. the French revolution, the Russian revolution, the American revolution, etc.

There are four levels in all societies:

1) the financial elites who control the

2) intellectuals who control the

3) warriors who control the

4) laborers.

As long as there is an equal flow of resources up and down this hierarchy, things remain calm. The New Deal of the 1930s redistributed wealth from the ruling elites to the middle and lower classes. For decades things seemed fair to everyone. But by the 1970s, the ruling elites said, “This is bullshit and it needs to change” (see the Lewis Powell Memo, 1971). From Ronald Reagan on, the financial elites have chipped away at the New Deal reforms.

Today they call things like Medicare and Social Security “entitlements,” as through we don’t deserve them or have not paid for them through taxation. The financial elites continue to try to destroy programs that might help the poor. Remember W trying to privatize Social Security? Remember Paul Ryan’s fear of what happens when “the safety net becomes a hammock?”

For the past four or five decades, the wealthy have been enriching themselves through numerous schemes that draw money from the middle and lower classes. Today, the top 0.1% own as much wealth as the bottom 90%. The top 1% owns more than the bottom 80%.

Most of this redistribution upward (reverse Robben Hood) has been accomplished via tax policy. Like Lucy and the football, we keep voting for the idea of “Trickle Down.” If we give the wealthy even more tax breaks they will create jobs. Did not work in  Reagan’s time, and still doesn’t. As the wealthy take it all, programs that make life bearable for everyone else are being hollowed out, or eliminated.  The result? Here are two homeless people in the shadow of Redwood City City Hall.



When I was young, California had a state hospital system paid for by taxes. People who were mentally ill, retarded, or drug addicted did not have to live and die on the street. We would not have tolerated this kind of thing back then. The tax payers just didn’t want to pay for it anymore, and Reagan closed the hospitals.

Now Trump callously destroys programs that might help the poor and disadvantaged get a leg up. What about healthcare for all? Education? Decent public housing? Job training? Meanwhile, the top .01% get richer and richer. Today there are 607 billionaires in our country. $68,000 wrist watches. $3M cars. Manhattan penthouses. Private jets and yachts. Our country is being turned into an oligarchy. No wonder there is rioting in the streets. If President Cheetos gets reelected, we can kiss our democracy good-bye.

How do we bring some of that wealth back down to create a decent country that helps people find the American Dream rather than finding cement bricks to smash store windows and burn down the neighborhood? I hope we are not heading into a full-on bloody revolution or civil war. One thing is clear, the uber- rich will not give up their wealth without a fight. Enter the police and national guard.

George Floyd was just the straw that broke our back. Fasten your seatbelt.


On A Lighter Note…

My wife, Mary, is a terrific cook. She has always wanted an herb garden. With lots of time on my hands during our sheltering-in-place, I put one together for her. I have been getting rid of my hundreds of audio cassettes. Have not played them for years. Since they cannot be recycled because of the Mylar tape, I decided to use them to build the herb garden. The cassettes were glued together with a glue gun and painted black. They were used for legs. Add three wooden planks, and we’d done.







6 thoughts on “It’s Not About George Floyd

  1. Susan Page says:

    Well, all I can say is AMEN, brother! Government that serves the Common Good is long gone. Can we ever get our democracy back? In the 20s, they called the robber barons, and what we see now is way worse. Let’s revive that term and at least name them for what they are! ROBBER BILLIONAIRES!

  2. Mark Shaw says:

    I see a class struggle too. And the increasing gap in wealth. But I don’t think that gets to the rage we see exploding from the what happened to George Floyd. This is about race as much as if not more than about class. Blacks are disproportionately impacted by police violence, by Covid 19, by the wage disparity you talked about. We are unable to address the racism that cuts through our nation.

    I am so disgusted by what happened to George Floyd, the repeated line “I can’t breathe” and repeated story of excessive force.

    I was afraid of Covid 19 but I am more afraid of this. There is no vaccine for this. We have to figure it out ourselves.

  3. Bob says:

    So well said and done, Rick. Your metaphor has been so strong it has lit up the whole world. Surely this will come to a good end. The four levels of society fit for all societies, generations, centuries. Is that your construction? I applaud your herb garden and how it’s supported. You have almost inspired me to action.

  4. Sara Geber says:

    I’ve been expecting something like this (the uprisings, not the pandemic) for awhile now. I’m actually surprised it took this long. Whenever I used to hear someone say they liked the policies of Reagan/Bush/Trump (pick your republican), I’d ask them “what part of revolution don’t you understand?” I think the U.S. is finished as a world leader. In these last few years, as our leadership was crumbling, we have proven that we now have nothing others in the world should want to emulate and much that has proven does NOT work. I’m no longer proud of this country or the capitalism it’s supposed to represent; I’m embarrassed. I cannot find any way to justify that capitalism works. I now consider myself a socialist or at least a social democrat. No, I have no idea what we should do from here to, as Mark says, “figure it out for ourselves.” How do we do that? Ironically and perversely, this is probably what people in the south were feeling when they seceded from the U.S. two centuries ago. I’d like to do that…just take a few other left-leaning states with us.

  5. George O. Petty says:

    When we were young (1950’s), people who were mentally ill, retarded, or drug addicted COULD NOT live and die on the street. We had places to put them–mental hospitals–and the legal right to do so. We, the voters, need to bring back both those hospitals and that right of “conservatorship.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *